This post includes spoilers.
So, I am going to talk about a book that I have
not read. Strange, isn't it?
Neither am I planning to read it. Hadn't even
heard of it until recently. No, I don't live under a rock (turns out it's a
bestselling book), I just live in a country far away and don't read
contemporary young adult books (although I write them).
Then why am I writing a post about
Divergent?
When checking Amazon's Top 100 list I stumbled
upon a low rated book, with over 1500 reviews. This reminded me of Charlaine
Harris' last Sookie installment. I thought, "Has to be a similar story.
Fans are angry about something."
Turns out I was right. Fans are angry. But not
angry just because it didn't end the way they wished. They are angry because
the main character dies in the end.
This raises an interesting question. Should
we kill off our protagonists?
My answer is NO. Not in this type of books.
Now, let me explain. Stories are not dogmas.They
can't begin and end the same way. But we, the authors, have to be careful with
what we write and for whom we write. You may not agree with me, but
contemporary young adult books are pure entertainment. Very few of them will
stand next to the classics (Harry Potter might be the lucky one). It doesn't
mean they don't teach our youth about good and bad, right or wrong, but in my
humble opinion, their first and foremost mission is entertaining.
And there is nothing wrong about entertaining the
reader. Now imagine if Ivanhoe, Quentin Durward, d'Artagnan,
or Tom Sawyer died at the end of the book.
Alright, imagine if Harry Potter
died.
We don't need them to die. And we don't want them to die. Because they
are a part of a world that gives us adventures, fun, and hope. Because we
already witness despair and cruelty. Every day. If I want to feel down, I will
turn on the TV and see what's happening in this crazy world. But when I grab a
book, I want a journey into another world, where the good always wins, hope
prevails, and love conquers everything.
It doesn't mean I pick a book with pink
eyeglasses on my nose. A lot depends on the genre. If it's young adult, then
it's not Dickens or Hardy. To me young adult means a story about a young
character or characters who will go through a life-changing
adventure, will lose and gain, will love and hate, and will learn important lessons of life
Too simple? Not really.
This same storyline has been entertaining us for
decades, if not for centuries. The story might have a sad ending, or a happy
ending, but the reader won't be left heartbroken
An exception that comes to my
mind is
Bridge to Terabithia. A wonderful movie, but I will never read the book
or re-watch the film. Because I once already cried my eyes out.
Now more and more
sad stories come to mind, but it turns out, they all had that sad but happy
ending. To Kill a Mockingbird is a good example. One of the saddest stories I
have read, which still ends on a positive note. It ends with hope. Catcher in
the Rye, another favorite of mine, also ends with hope.
It's amazing how much power we have as authors.
We create, we entertain, and we give hope. Why would we leave our readers
heartbroken, when we could give them a reward in the end? A satisfying ending
they have hoped for. An ending they deserve.
Let's love our readers more, shall we? <3